After watching the trailer for Smurfs, I was conflicted as to whether to watch the movie or not. The trailer unfortunately didn’t do much in convincing me that this was a must see. Regardless, I decided to watch the movie before passing any judgements, cos sometimes, trailers can be misleading, and sometimes the film itself delivers where the promo doesn’t.
So I decided to take my kids to watch the latest instalment of the Smurfs yesterday and quiet frankly, I felt like I lost a few brain cells after sitting through what can only be described as a chaotic, humourless mess wrapped in blue paint and corporate glitter. The latest Smurfs movie feels like a nostalgia-fuelled train that’s derailed somewhere between bad casting and baffling storytelling choices. What should have been a charming return to blue magic instead felt like a confused, watered-down mess that can’t decide what kind of film it wants to be.
The humour? Practically non-existent. The once playful, mischievous wit of the Smurfs has been replaced by forced gags and flat dialogue. It’s as if the writers forgot that the magic of The Smurfs wasn’t just in the visuals, but in the heart and comedy that made them iconic. Instead, we were left with cringeworthy one-liners that even kids weren’t laughing at.
And then there’s Gargamel, the villain we love to hate, or at least used to. His role in this film flips so many times, it’s dizzying. One minute he’s trying to destroy the Smurfs, the next he’s helping them just to spite his brother. After the many years of trying to capture the Smurfs, I hardly think that, his reasoning is actually reason worthy for his change of heart. The inconsistency in his behaviour ruins the tension and erodes any sense of real stakes. When your antagonist feels like a last-minute rewrite, the entire narrative suffers.
But perhaps the most eyebrow-raising decision was casting Rihanna as Smurfette. A bold choice? Yes. A good one? Not really. Rihanna’s voice just doesn’t capture the essence of Smurfette, at least not for me. The innocence, the emotional nuance, or even the comic timing, was nowhere to be found. It feels like stunt casting over character alignment, and it threw the whole dynamic off. Smurfette who used to be the emotional anchor of the group, now feels like a brand mascot dropped into the wrong franchise.
This latest installment felt more like a brand exercise than a meaningful continuation of a beloved world. For longtime fans such as me, I found it extremely frustrating and underwhelming. For kids, it’s forgettable. And for everyone in between, it’s a reminder that even the brightest shade of blue can turn dull when the story loses its heart.
