If you listen closely, you can almost hear the creak of the Black Pearl’s mast and the faint echo of Jack Sparrow’s drunken wisdom floating on the wind: “Not all treasure is silver and gold, mate.” And he’s right, sometimes, the real treasure is a long-awaited reunion. That’s exactly what fans of the Pirates of the Caribbean saga have been whispering about ever since Orlando Bloom dropped anchor and spoke candidly about the possibility of setting sail once again.
In a recent chat with Deadline, Bloom, our forever Will Turner, got honest about the one thing that might actually bring the franchise back to life. Amongst other things, a solid script and ideally, the return of the entire gang is on top of the list. Because, as he puts it, “Everything is in the writing, right? Everything is on the page.” A pirate may live by the sword, but a great movie? That lives by the script.
In his conversation with, Bloom didn’t shy away from the big question, will he return to the seas? His answer was refreshingly human. He’d love to. But only if the story deserves it. “I would personally love to see everybody back,” he said, echoing the same sentiment on other platforms that’s been stirring waves online. It’s not a full-speed-ahead declaration, but rather a sailor’s cautious optimism. As Bloom stated, “I think they’re trying to work out what it would all look like.” Translation: the ship’s not quite ready to leave port, but the compass is pointing in the right direction.
What makes Bloom’s comments resonate isn’t just his longing for old times, it’s his awareness that you can’t just slap a bandana on nostalgia and call it a comeback. He knows the script has to earn its place in the franchise’s legacy. And with Disney reportedly weighing multiple Pirates projects (including a reboot and a potential spin-off), Bloom’s cautious stance feels less like reluctance and more like a captain waiting for the right wind.
Still, he’s clear about one thing: “The way to win on that one is to get everybody back. If they can, and if everybody wanted to go back.” You can almost picture the original crew with Depp, Knightley and Rush, gathered around the rum barrel, trying to decide whether another voyage is worth it.
Of course, the waters are murky. Between franchise fatigue, changing creative hands, and shifting studio priorities, Pirates has been drifting in the doldrums for years. Yet Bloom’s comments, earnest and grounded feel like a reminder of why the series worked in the first place. It wasn’t just the CGI krakens or cursed gold. It was the crew. The dysfunctional, chaotic, unforgettable crew. And maybe that’s the secret map we’ve all been missing. A reunion isn’t about reliving the past, it’s about rekindling the chemistry that made us fall in love with these characters in the first place.
If you really think about it, Pirates of the Caribbean without Will Turner and Elizabeth Swann is like rum without the kick. Bloom’s openness to returning feels like a small spark of hope for fans who never quite got over the salty charm of the original trilogy. But he’s right, the magic begins with the writing. Get that wrong, and even the Black Pearl can’t stay afloat.
So yes, bring back the swords, the swagger, and the sea spray, but most importantly, bring back the heart. Because as Captain Jack would probably slur between sips of rum: “The problem is not the problem. The problem is the lack of a good script.”
And that, mates, might just be the truest thing ever said on the seven seas.
